all-Rhoads team

[DesertClone1]

Arnaud over Jantz and any qb that Rhoads coached by a mile. Irving needs to be in there somewhere on the DL, he will likely have more of an impact in the NFL than everyone on the defense list combined. Sims over Washington. Franklin over Bibbs.

Arnaud was a Chiz recruit

 

[Cyinthenorth]

Arnaud was a Chiz recruit

Developed by CPR

 

[DesertClone1]

Developed by CPR

Developed poorly... Had better stats his one year under Chiz

 

[LB52]

Developed by CPR

Not really. IMO Rhoads ruined his career by turning him into a zone read qb. His sophomore year under Chizik was by far his best year here and ended that season looking like a future pro. He had all the tools to be a great qb under Mac's system too. He was never meant to be a spread QB.

 

[cyclones500]

QB: arnaud
RB: arob
WR: lazard
WR: Reynolds
WR: Darks
TE: Bibbs
Ot: osemele
Og: omoile
Ot: Bykowski
Og: Burton
C: Stephens

De: Morrissey
DT: McDonough
DT: Tucker
De: Scott
LB: Knott
Lb: Klein
Lb: George
S: kcm
S: Bromfield
CB: Reeves
CB: Watson
K:Mahoney
P: Kirby
KR/PR: West

I like the addition of West as returner.

 

[cyclones500]

Arnaud was a Chiz recruit

Arnaud was a McCarney recruit.

 

[Erik4Cy]

QB: arnaud
RB: arob
WR: lazard
WR: Reynolds
WR: Darks
TE: Bibbs
Ot: osemele
Og: omoile
Ot: Bykowski
Og: Burton
C: Stephens

De: Morrissey
DT: McDonough
DT: Tucker
De: Scott
LB: Knott
Lb: Klein
Lb: George
S: kcm
S: Bromfield
CB: Reeves
CB: Watson
K:Mahoney
P: Kirby
KR/PR: West

That would've been a sick team. You left out Leonard Johnson at CB though, I'd go him over Jansen Watson. Too bad Rhoads teams were always lacking somewhere each year. LBs were absolutely incredible for awhile though. Consistency and development at QB really hurt his teams too. All the QBs did things well, but never truly pieced it all together. Hopefully some lights turn on for our QBs under Campbell they way they did for our LBs under Rhoads.

 

[xboxfever]

Arnaud was a Chiz recruit

Arnaud was a Mac recruit that Chiz inherited.

 

[LB52]

Developed poorly... Had better stats his one year under Chiz

This. If by "developed" you mean having his career ruined, then yes, Rhoads developed him. I don't care what anyone says, he looked like he could have been the best qb in ISU history the way he ended his first year under Chizik. 440 passing yards and 3 TD's in his last game, I believe 300+ yards the game before that. Then Rhoads comes in and makes him a zone read qb...

 

[Cyinthenorth]

This. If by "developed" you mean having his career ruined, then yes, Rhoads developed him. I don't care what anyone says, he looked like he could have been the best qb in ISU history the way he ended his first year under Chizik. 440 passing yards and 3 TD's in his last game, I believe 300+ yards the game before that. Then Rhoads comes in and makes him a zone read qb...

Point well taken. Memory of that era is foggy apparently

 

[Cytasticlone]

QB: arnaud
RB: arob
WR: lazard
WR: Reynolds
WR: Darks
TE: Bibbs
Ot: osemele
Og: omoile
Ot: Bykowski
Og: Burton
C: Stephens

De: Morrissey
DT: McDonough
DT: Tucker
De: Scott
LB: Knott
Lb: Klein
Lb: George
S: kcm
S: Bromfield
CB: Reeves
CB: Watson
K:Mahoney
P: Kirby
KR/PR: West

I like this list. I would probably sub in Bundrage and Farniock at WR and C, but this is really good.

 

[CyArob]

Developed by CPR

That's a bad thing.

 

[dualthreat]

There's no reason to put Darius Darks ahead of Josh Lenz. Or even Quenton Bundrage

 

[AMarner32]

There's no reason to put Darius Darks ahead of Josh Lenz. Or even Quenton Bundrage

Lenz has to be on the team simply for versatility's sake. Could return, catch, and even pass. Plus I think he was a four year starter (and a good guy).

 

[ghettocowboy4cy]

Was Jon Banks a chiz guy as well as David sims?

 

[Rabbuk]

Darius Darks... lol... nope.

 

[cyclones500]

There's no reason to put Darius Darks ahead of Josh Lenz. Or even Quenton Bundrage

I agree. Lenz is on the team.

 

[VeloClone]

This is clearly a Rhoads team the OP put together as there is no depth.