Cyclone Comparison Team

Bardman

Active Member
Dec 7, 2009
735
85
28
Mesa, AZ
So a lot of NBA player comparisons have been thrown around by Hoiberg and members of the media which made me wonder what the team of comparisons would look like. I would imagine we could throw together a pretty solid all time list, but I'll start with this years team.

Here's what I come up with:

Monte Morris
"Mateen Cleaves"

BDJ
"JR Smith"

Abdel Nader
"Nicholas Batum"

Dustin Hogue
"Kenneth Faried"

Georges Niang
"Kevin Love"

McKay
"DeMarre Carroll/Kenneth Faried"
 

clonedude

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2006
33,045
29,296
113
Monte Morris reminds me of Kevin Johnson from the Suns from years ago for some reason. Anyone else see that?

Niang's outside shooting form (not necessarily the results, just his form) reminds me of Larry Bird. I wish Niang had Bird's fadeway shot though.
 

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,682
80,072
113
DSM
Morris - Steve Blake
BDJ - Russell Westbrook
Nader - Michael Beasley
Niang - Zach Randolph
McKay - Faried

These change for me all of the time so whatever, this is what I'm feeling tonight.
 

cyclones12321

Well-Known Member
Feb 21, 2009
8,258
1,772
113
38
Newton Ia
So a lot of NBA player comparisons have been thrown around by Hoiberg and members of the media which made me wonder what the team of comparisons would look like. I would imagine we could throw together a pretty solid all time list, but I'll start with this years team.

Here's what I come up with:

Monte Morris
"Mateen Cleaves"

BDJ
"JR Smith"

Abdel Nader
"Nicholas Batum"

Dustin Hogue
"Kenneth Faried"

Georges Niang
"Kevin Love"

McKay
"DeMarre Carroll/Kenneth Faried"

Morris /rondo
 

GottaTri

Member
Jul 26, 2012
62
26
18
I think Niang reminds me much more of Boris Diaw from the Spurs than anyone else mentioned so far for his counterpart.
 

Clone9

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2006
3,266
1,177
113
Boston, MA
Diaw is a good comparison for Niang. I have always thought he was like Gary Trent with a 3 pt shot....
 

cycfan1

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2006
4,896
2,275
113
Ames
Morris - Steve Blake
BDJ - Russell Westbrook
Nader - Michael Beasley
Niang - Zach Randolph
McKay - Faried

These change for me all of the time so whatever, this is what I'm feeling tonight.

I'm sorry, but these are all pretty poor.

Everyone keeps saying McKay is like Faried. Just saw him play is DSM last week. No chance in the world McKay is anything like him. Just doesn't have the weight to push around.
 

bawbie

Moderator
Staff member
Mar 17, 2006
54,370
47,073
113
Cedar Rapids, IA
I'm sorry, but these are all pretty poor.Everyone keeps saying McKay is like Faried. Just saw him play is DSM last week. No chance in the world McKay is anything like him. Just doesn't have the weight to push around.
McKay is within 10 pounds of what Faried played at in college. But size isn't the real comparison, motor, rebounding and finishing are the similarities.

The other one I've heard recently is Niang - Draymond Green.
 
Last edited:

cycfan1

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2006
4,896
2,275
113
Ames
McKay is within 5 pounds of what Faried played at in college. The other one I've heard recently is Niang - Draymond Green.

I see McKay being much more of a long "soft' post player. Not a bad thing, just will get rebounds because of positioning and height and hops, not because of work ethic like Houge or Faried. That's not a knock on McKay. Just a finesse game with high flying outbacks. A Tyrus Thomas type.

Not sure Niang has a good comparison. Too unique.
 

cyclones500

Well-Known Member
Jan 29, 2010
38,858
26,898
113
Michigan
basslakebeacon.com
Monte Morris reminds me of Kevin Johnson from the Suns from years ago for some reason. Anyone else see that?

Niang's outside shooting form (not necessarily the results, just his form) reminds me of Larry Bird. I wish Niang had Bird's fadeway shot though.

Interesting with the Bird comparison. I still think of Kevin McHale-Niang comparison for form, footwork & finesse around the hoop on offense. Plenty of differences between the two (McHale a true power forward, Niang better from 3, for example), so that may be a bad comparison for overall game.
 

bawbie

Moderator
Staff member
Mar 17, 2006
54,370
47,073
113
Cedar Rapids, IA
I see McKay being much more of a long "soft' post player. Not a bad thing, just will get rebounds because of positioning and height and hops, not because of work ethic like Houge or Faried. That's not a knock on McKay. Just a finesse game with high flying outbacks. A Tyrus Thomas type.

That's not what I've heard about and seen from McKay. Everything I've heard is that his motor and work ethic is off the charts, even better than Hogue. Sure he isn't going to push anyone out of the post or out of position, but from what I've heard he isn't going to be out-hustled.
 

cyclones12321

Well-Known Member
Feb 21, 2009
8,258
1,772
113
38
Newton Ia
Morris - rondo (pass first, flashy, good ball handlers and also simular bodies)

Bdj - jr smith (simular bodies with major athleticism and a smooth shot. Hopefully bdj isn't a ball hog or dbag like smith though.)

Naz long - jason terry (both 6th man with an amazing 3 pt shot.)

Hogue - faried (both undersized fowards with athleticism and are very aggressive. Great rebounders. )

Nader - Batum (simply because of looks and body shape. Haven't really seen much of his game)

Niang - diaw (kudos to whoever came up with that comparison. Best comparison of the bunch. Both awesome passers, stretch 4's, undersized for their position with no athleticism but amazing ball handling skills. Oh not to mention both will have a championship after this year ;)

Mckay - larry sanders (both big with major athleticism and good shot blockers and rebounders)
 

cyclones12321

Well-Known Member
Feb 21, 2009
8,258
1,772
113
38
Newton Ia
imagejpeg

Not sure what that means lol
 

Cyientist

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 18, 2013
3,874
4,774
113
Ankeny
Agree with the Niang and Diaw comparisons. Before I saw the NBA championship last year I always thought Niang and Jared Dudley were comparable. Niang has more of a post up game now, but in the NBA I could see him needing to play more like Dudley.
 

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,859
66,300
113
LA LA Land
Obviously not saying he's at this level, but for Morris I'd say John Stockton. Not the flashiest, soft spoken but hard nosed, extremely efficient and in control, not a shoot first guard but seems to hit the shots when they matter.

Toward the end of the year was becoming a menace stealing the ball, think he led the team in steals which is crazy considering he didn't play that many minutes the first half of the season and guys like Naz, Kane, Ejim and Hogue were all over the place on D but didn't get as many steals..
 

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,859
66,300
113
LA LA Land
Hogue - Rodman . Not just a motor but a fire and sense of fight with the way he dunks and rips down boards

Also for getting in opponents heads, he and Ejim and Kane all had a mean streak last year that we really fed off of. Really glad Hogue is back for that reason among others.
 

TurbulentEddie

Active Member
Nov 16, 2012
891
204
43
Madison, WI
In terms of his post game, Niang reminds me of Zach Randolph. Very good at using his body to create space. Of course, that comparison breaks down when it comes to Niang's driving, shooting, and passing capabilities. I think the Diaw comparison works there, but Diaw is a better rebounder.

How about Robert Horry for Naz Long :jimlad:
 

Stewski

Member
Jul 3, 2014
38
4
8
Lawrence
If we are talking current NBA player comparisons here is my list

Monte Morris- Mike Conley Jr.- Both have good speed and quickness and play very smart. Even though Morris isn't considered by some to be the ISU's best shooter, he certainly should be. Both can shoot the rock off the dribble and catch and shoot. As for defense, Morris will mature just like Conley and become a very capable defender. Both were small but have room to bulk up.

Clayton Custer- Tony Parker- I haven't seen him yet but from what I've read and heard I'd say this would be a good comparison. Very typical point guards. Both are very fast with the ball in their control. Smart players that finish great close to the rim. Both also have a great mid-range game with decent 3 pt shooting. Parker has developed a 3 pt shot in the NBA as of recent and I've heard Custer isn't the greatest trey ball shooter.

BDJ- Nick Young/Swaggy P- Great athleticism and smooth shooting on the wing, but it comes down to consistency.
Other possibility O.J. Mayo

Nazty Long- Marco Belinelli- Excellent shooters with a very quick shot, takes shots off dribble and off screens very well and can shoot with defenders in face. He can also get to the rim.

Matt Thomas- J.J. Redick- White 3pt shooters that move very well off the ball and coming off screens. Thomas might be a little more athletic. Just want to throw this out there, but I like the Fred Hoiberg comparison too, just for poos and gigs.

Abdel Nader- Nicholas Batum- Lengthy wings that can shoot, and play great D.

Dustin Hogue- Jimmy "Buckets" Butler- Undersized and underrated forwards with great motors and athleticism. Jimmy is known for playing a lot of minutes and great D. I feel like the same can be said of the Hoguenator, the Hogueroni, the Hougester. Both can score if they have too, and can play either guard or forward in the NBA.

Georges Niang- Gordon Hayward- Plays PF in college, too small so switches to SF in NBA, but can play multiple positions. Not the best defenders or most athletic players on the court, but they possess great body control and shoot well outside, making them difficult to defend. Both also share an extremely high basketball IQ as well.

Jameel Mckay- Taj Gibson- High energy, athletic players that can run the floor. Undersized NBA PF's that make up for it with length, energy, and leaping ability. Dunk, and dunk hard. Fun to watch. They can defend multiple positions, throw back opposing shots, finish at the rim, have decent handling skills, have surprising quickness for their size, and have developing mid-range games.

Excited for this season to roll around, Go cyclones.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron