Can't both things be true? Prohms big bust of a 2019 class came hot on the heels of a really good season too. The 2024 class for Iowa State is only 2 kids, so if you are only 50% successful on a class of two it doesn't hurt as bad. I was just drawing a comparison. I don't at all think we are about to enter the doldrums or anything. Just stating that a player exiting the program prior to the season and prior to ever actually putting on a jersey reminded me of the 2019 debacle.
The 2019 squad finished 23-12 (9-9) and earned a #6 seed and lost in the first round to a #11 after winning the Big 12 tournament. It went 8-7 in Q1 games and 3-4 in Q2 games (undefeated Q3/Q4).
The 2024 squad finished 29-8 (13-5) in a tougher conference and earned a #2 seed (some argument was made for a #1) and lost in the Sweet Sixteen to a #3 after winning the Big 12 tournament. It went 10-6 in Q1 games and 6-1 in Q2 games (only loss was VT in Orlando, undefeated Q3/Q4).
2019 was a good season. 2024 was an exceptional one.
Departures after 2019 included Nick Weiler-Babb (a solid college PG), Marial Shayok (first-team all-Big 12), Lindell Wigginton (a fringe NBA shooting guard), Cameron Lard (obviously a headcase but a spectacular talent when "Good Lard" showed up), and future NBA journeyman Talen-Horton Tucker.
Replacements included... Prentiss Nixon, Javan Johnson, Rasir Bolton, and freshman Tre Jackson and freshman Caleb Grill. Some okay players there, but nobody I'd call all that special of a guy. Nixon was a chucker, Johnson wasn't a Big 12 player, Bolton was out for himself, Jackson seemed like a good kid but wasn't a Big 12 player, and Grill needed another season (at least) to develop to play at this level effectively.
Departures after 2024 included Tre King/Robert Jones/Hason Ward (so most of your front court minutes, though none were world beaters and have been replaced by equivalent talents in Joshua Jefferson, Dishon Jackson, Brandton Chatfield, and JT Rock coming off a redshirt and plus you've still got Milan and Demarion who can play the "4" in a smaller lineup) and then a few guys who never really saw the court.
Most of the talent and experience from the 2019 roster departed.
The core of the 2024 roster returns... four potential all-Big 12 guys in Tamin, KG, CuJo, and Milan.
We don't know where Pierce is going to end up. Wouldn't shock me to see him at St. John's or in one of the better mid-major conferences in the Northeast. Leech and Anderson transferred to D2 schools.
So, no, I don't see the circumstances as comparable.