NDSU BISON @ Iowa State University Cyclones

Status
Not open for further replies.

cycloneG

Well-Known Member
Mar 7, 2007
15,995
16,629
113
Off the grid
Valid point. But I still wouldn't say West Virginia struggled the one year they had Geno, as i am pretty sure they made a bowl game that year, and if making a bowl game is a struggling season, i hate to think what you guys call non bowl game seasons-- or most seasons.

Barely qualifying for a bowl game (6-6) after coming off a conference championship and a BCS bowl berth is struggling.
 

BYYYYEZON

Member
Aug 14, 2014
54
1
8
38
Do you think Kansas State was overlooking you guys not to mention trying to find a new quarterback? Our offense was not good because of our O-coordinator. Before we lost our confidence we competed against Texas and Texas Tech, we went down hill because of injuries, quarterback injury and bad bad coordinating. Don't overlook us.

Kansas State's Qb, ratings wise, had his 3rd or 4th best game against all year against us. He did not struggle. 21/29 with 280 yards and 2 td's is not struggling nor looking ahead. He made one big mistake, but it let to no points as our kicker missed the FG. He played well, as did their skill players, lockett and thompson, but they still only scored 21.

I get that your offense very well could be much improved this year with a new coordinator, and it sounds like you have a ton of good skill guys as well. But if you think you will be marching up and down the field on us, i think you will be in for a big disappointment. As i said earlier, i don't know who is going to win the game, but if iowa state is going to win, stopping the Bison O would be a good start, because your 500 + yards and ridiculous stats you had in the last two games last year isn't happening.
 

ribsnwhiskey

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Feb 6, 2009
9,080
4,306
113
80246
I'm not overlooking you, just simply arguing a mere opinion against the claim that ISU's starters are better at 19-20 of 22 positions according to some ISU posters. You disagreed that NDSU's defense would be better than ISU's so I was wondering if there is anything you thought NDSU would have an advantage in.

19-20 of 22? Try 22-22.
 

FGsareforsucker

New Member
Oct 4, 2013
27
0
1
Even if those all are true (which I believe they are), in no way would that make the line 49 points.. They mean we think our team will win. Do you not understand that the experts in Vegas don't make lines based on who they think will win, but rather what will yield the most even bets from each side??

I know the line would not be 49, a bit of hyperbole for the wrestling guy. And yes I know they try to get the most even bets on both sides, but they do also have to set it close to what they think the result will be and they have to be good at figuring that out.
 

BYYYYEZON

Member
Aug 14, 2014
54
1
8
38
I'll agree that last year's NDSU team was special. However, even that NDSU team gets 5 to 7 wins AT MOST against ISU's 2013 schedule. Even if you want to give NDSU the additional scholarships, still no more than 7 wins, likely 6-6. NDSU beat UNI and KSU last year so I will count that as two wins. I think they could have beat Tulsa, a TCU team with no offense, Kansas, and WVU. Maybe someone else. If you want to argue that last year's NDSU team was one of the best FCS teams ever that's fine, but they still would have been a .500 football team in the Big 12. They would not have "competed with anyone in the nation" as you say.

That's fine. I get that is most people's opinion. If they played Oklahoma or Texas in the middle of last year, they would have been 2 1/2 and 4 1/2 point underdogs on a neutral field, according to Sagarin, and Vegas usually isn't more than 3-4 points of what Sagarin has. So yeah, neutral field under 5 point underdogs last year? That's the most objective view i can find, and i would say that is competing. Maybe they would have finished .500, or maybe they would have finished 8-2 IDK. They would have been competitive in every game they played though, and after watching the horses up front man handle kansas state on the road, it would have been interesting to see those 4 conference home games. I do KNOW they would NOT be able to compete year and year out with the 63 scholarships and have NO idea how they would do with 85 scholarships. I am not making those predictions, just saying last year's team would have been competitive with anyone in the big 12.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/sport...arin-speaks-north-dakota-state-bison/3645173/
 

Cyclones_R_GR8

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Feb 10, 2007
23,987
25,973
113
Omaha
I know the line would not be 49, a bit of hyperbole for the wrestling guy. And yes I know they try to get the most even bets on both sides, but they do also have to set it close to what they think the result will be and they have to be good at figuring that out.
Or maybe Vegas is making the line as such so they can get their hands on all the OIL MONEY ! ! !
 

WrestlerJJE

Active Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Feb 6, 2014
431
63
28
32
Ames, Iowa
I'm not overlooking you, just simply arguing a mere opinion against the claim that ISU's starters are better at 19-20 of 22 positions according to some ISU posters. You disagreed that NDSU's defense would be better than ISU's so I was wondering if there is anything you thought NDSU would have an advantage in.
My honest opinion, I will tell you that will score based on how young our defense is. I am still waiting on someone to comment me back on how big your line will be but i am assuming that it will be big. That is your advantage. You lost your best CB out there, you are working with a new coach who has not showed how well he has coached being the top dog, there are so many variables that for both of us to say which one will be better. I am also pointing out is that this year will be different. You people do not understand how bad it was on offense. we were so bad in that area because of the way it was ran. I got this on twitter, 48% of our drives were 3 and outs. Ok, you cannot blame that all on the kids, they are athletic enough. What I am saying is that there is better and kids that have playing time. I predicted that score because of the way the confidence is and hungry they sound. They are tired of losing, I can tell. But it is such a wild card for both of us that I cannot say who is going to be better and who won't.
 

awd4cy

Well-Known Member
Dec 29, 2010
28,014
19,627
113
Central Iowa
The delusion from Bison fans is as strong here as it is on Bisonville. I think those fans really did just start following football 5 years ago.
 

FGsareforsucker

New Member
Oct 4, 2013
27
0
1
19-20 of 22? Try 22-22.

Speaking of arrongance...And despite being better at every position the odds makers have you a home underdog to an FCS team. Must be fun to be a cyclone fan. How bad is your program that an FCS team with 63 scholarships, with a 25year old 19000 seat dome, with a tiny coaching salaries budget, from a no-nameconference in a tiny state that lost 11ish starters, its head coach and offensivecoordinator is favored over your team that is in one of the BIG 5 prestigious power conferences with a 50,000 seat stadium, 85 scholarships and a comparatively enormous athletic budget.
 

WrestlerJJE

Active Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Feb 6, 2014
431
63
28
32
Ames, Iowa
Kansas State's Qb, ratings wise, had his 3rd or 4th best game against all year against us. He did not struggle. 21/29 with 280 yards and 2 td's is not struggling nor looking ahead. He made one big mistake, but it let to no points as our kicker missed the FG. He played well, as did their skill players, lockett and thompson, but they still only scored 21.

I get that your offense very well could be much improved this year with a new coordinator, and it sounds like you have a ton of good skill guys as well. But if you think you will be marching up and down the field on us, i think you will be in for a big disappointment. As i said earlier, i don't know who is going to win the game, but if iowa state is going to win, stopping the Bison O would be a good start, because your 500 + yards and ridiculous stats you had in the last two games last year isn't happening.
Did I say that we were going to curb stomp you? I just simply said that offense will be drastically improved especially when Mangino is coaching us.
 

WrestlerJJE

Active Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Feb 6, 2014
431
63
28
32
Ames, Iowa
Speaking of arrongance...And despite being better at every position the odds makers have you a home underdog to an FCS team. Must be fun to be a cyclone fan. How bad is your program that an FCS team with 63 scholarships, with a 25year old 19000 seat dome, with a tiny coaching salaries budget, from a no-nameconference in a tiny state that lost 11ish starters, its head coach and offensivecoordinator is favored over your team that is in one of the BIG 5 prestigious power conferences with a 50,000 seat stadium, 85 scholarships and a comparatively enormous athletic budget.
It's called being overrated......
 

Rabbuk

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2011
56,961
46,118
113
See the difference between us and you is that we know we suck in the grand scheme of things. We just are more significant than you. We at least play in the majors, while you guys are playing for triple A championships. Can anyone name who won the championship for Triple A last year?
 

isutrevman

Well-Known Member
Jan 30, 2007
7,372
9,952
113
38
Ames, IA
T-5th at a 4-5 record. You are saying West Virginia has sucked since joining the big 12 since they were from a lesser conference, and that NDSU would get ***** stomped. I don't think 4-5 in the big 12 and tied for 5th is getting **** stomped, nor prove your point. The 2-7 record after the year he left would, but again, they didn't have a QB. I never said nor thought that West Virginia or TCU would win the big 12 with Dalton and Smith, rather they wouldn't struggle so bad if those two were running those respective teams. Dalton didn't play in the big 12 after leading his team to a 13-0 record his senior year, so saying TCU has struggled so badly because they joined the big 12 needs to temper down a bit.

So where is NDSU's 1st-2nd round draft pick QB that would keep them from sucking in the Big 12?
 

awd4cy

Well-Known Member
Dec 29, 2010
28,014
19,627
113
Central Iowa
Speaking of arrongance...And despite being better at every position the odds makers have you a home underdog to an FCS team. Must be fun to be a cyclone fan. How bad is your program that an FCS team with 63 scholarships, with a 25year old 19000 seat dome, with a tiny coaching salaries budget, from a no-nameconference in a tiny state that lost 11ish starters, its head coach and offensivecoordinator is favored over your team that is in one of the BIG 5 prestigious power conferences with a 50,000 seat stadium, 85 scholarships and a comparatively enormous athletic budget.
Well for 1, I would much rather be on our side than yours. Thanks for making me feel even better about ourselves. All that must suck for you.
 

BYYYYEZON

Member
Aug 14, 2014
54
1
8
38
Lol at this fool thinking they'd be competitive with Oklahoma.

I didn't write that, and actually i misquoted the article Sagarin would have favored us last year on a neutral field, and as he is pretty close to line with Vegas, there is no way we would have been more than a touchdown Dog on a neutral field. I believe his quote at the end is questioning the intellect of anyone who can't comprehend that. Whatever, last year is last year, but we do have a good defense returning. This will be a low scoring game.
 

awd4cy

Well-Known Member
Dec 29, 2010
28,014
19,627
113
Central Iowa
That certainly might be the case. NDSU certainly has some question marks. But I will trust a neutral odds maker over a cyclone fan that asserts that ISU is better at every single position as at least one fan has.
Well the line has done nothing but move towards us so I guess many people aren't so confident in your pee-wee football team from Fargo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.