I am a little bored at work today as I don't have much to do until 4. So with the recent draft in mind I wanted to look back at our recruits a little bit. I am using Rivals stars and rating for comparison. I just would note that we signed a lot of 2 star recruits and many of them were significantly below the 5.5 threshold for three starts.
Carter Bykowski (2008, Chiz recruit), TE, 2 stars, 5.1 rating
Leonard Johnson (same) ATH, 3 stars, 5.5
Roosevelt Maggitt (same) DE, 2 stars, 5.3
Jake McDonough (same) DE, 3 stars, 5.5
(all are Chiz recruits but were mostly developed by Rhoads and the current staff) Really not too bad considering three of the four are now signed or playing in the NFL.
A.J. Klein (2009, Rhoads), 3 stars, 5.5 rating (drafted 5th round?)
Jake Knott (same), 2 star, 5.4 (signed free agent)
Josh Lenz, 2 star, 5.2 (signed free agent)
Jeremy Reeves, 2 star, 5.1 (not sure?)
Willie Scott, 2 star, 5.2 (starting)
Jacques Washington, 2 star, 5.2 (starting)
Jansen Watson, 2 star, 5.3 (top starting corner?)
James White, 3 stars, 5.5 (significant # of starts)
Walter Woods, 2 star, 5.4 (starting)
Anyway, I think that was one heck of a first class that the coaches put together in a short period of time if I remember correctly. It also shows that they can develop players at many of these positions and get the most out of them. However, IMO stars definitely do matter especially at the skill positions as you just can't coach that kind of athleticism. I just glanced at WVU's list and noted their 2009 commits, Tavon Austin, 4 stars, 5.8 rating (and #8 pick this year), Stedman Bailey, 4 stars, 5.8 rating (drafted 2nd round?), and Geno "Cry baby" Smith, 4 stars, 5.9 rating.
Just my 30 minutes of wasting time but just reinforced my admiration of what this staff has been able to accomplish. It also points to why I'm (and everyone) should be so excited to see what a highly ranked skill guy like Allen Lazard might be able to do at ISU.