It's not a question of failure or anything. But I don't see how you can argue that we've been as successful in convincing highy sought after HS kids to choose ISU as we have with top transfers and JUCOs.
Royce was a former 5* being recruited by UK; McKay was a top 10 JUCO who quickly transferred here. BDJ had to have been one of the top 10 sought after transfers, as I assume Kane was. Our excellent HS players have been guys that developed to a great degree (Ejim) or were under-ranked, and therefore under recruited coming out of HS (Niang, Morris, etc.) compared to what they clearly should have been.
I have to assume it's just a small sample size issue that will disappear in the next few years, but it just seems odd to me.