I don't have to be an astronaut that has walked on the moon to know it's not made of cheese!
I have coached...certainly never at a major college. Then again, I have never claimed that I did.
I have not evaluated any recruits here on this site. I have just expressed some sincere skepticism about kids from small Nebraska towns that score 30 a night being able to translate that into dramatic impact at a major college BB program. The examples being given to the contrary (Mike Miller, etc) notwithstanding...the reality is that it is the exception, rather than the rule, to see this type of kid excel on the next level (assuming a major DI program).
At the end of the day, if it is required that we have coached an NCAA team in order to comment on a coach or that we have played at a major college in order to comment on the players at ISU then my guess is that there would be virtually no discussion at all on this board.
Maybe, we should only allow former Presidents to vote for President too! How can the rest of us idiots possibly know what it takes to be President?!
Loren Meyer and Homan did okay from a small school.