It's a little hard to say because there is not a more jacked up power conference program in the country than MSU right now. But Hill wasn't that bad. Better than Petras. Their receivers did him no favors. Combine the drops with balls that technically weren't drops but balls that they should probably at least catch once in a while. Vines reminds me of a typical Rhoads-era ISU receiver. We get all excited for him, then watch him play and see his catch radius is basically zero. Not a good combo with anything other than a super-accurate QB.I watched the MSU game later. I didn’t think Hill was that bad….quicker feet than I expected after reading comments here. Strong arm tho looks like he lacks touch. Should be good for QB sneaks.
McNamara was a sitting duck in the pocket.
But so far this season McNamara is considerably worse than I thought he'd be, and certainly worse than the revisionist history will portray the farther out we get from seeing him play.