Well its the end of a week-long pumpkin beer tasting, so I guess I should power rank them like the thread title says. We'll use the diamond ratings (since I don't see any characters for stars). My ratings are just as reliable as sites that use stars for recruits, as those are entertainment sites and this is a beer entertainment ranking.
1. Howe Sound Pumpkineater. ♦♦♦♦♦ If CFH recruited beer, he'd get this one. Fantastic taste. Hands down the best.
2. Alewerks Pumkpin Ale. ♦♦♦♦ Definitely recommend this pumpkin beer too, very good.
3. Saranac Pumpkin Ale. This is interesting, if you're a Bud Light / Miller Light kind of person and that is your nectar, then this is for you. You'd say ♦♦♦♦, people who like richer flavor probably would say its like water. This is the type of beer if you're looking at a night game and have a long day of tailgating ahead. It won't fill you up and you can drink it all day. Personally I liked it, probably ♦♦♦½.
4. Anderson Valley Fall Hornin'. ♦♦♦½. Malty like I said before. Worth getting.
5. Dogfish Punkin Ale. ♦♦½. Didn't have the spice of others so it didn't give as much of a pumpkin feel. Kind of meh.
6. Terrapin Pumpkinfest. ♦. Based on the number of diamonds as people like to say, "Don't want."
7. Pumpkin Hunter. ♦. This is not a diamond in the rough that Paul Rhoads found and is going to make into an all-pumpkin-beer candidate. Ever.
