Pumpkin beer power rankings
- Thread starter ChrisMWilliams
- Start date
Just coming here to post this. Target didn't have any Schlafly last night, and I didn't wanna make another stop, so I settled for Shock Top. Not good.
I've tried Schlafly and O'Fallon so far this year. They're certainly different beers, but if I had to choose, I think I'd go with O'Fallon.
Wantin to pick up some pumpkin beer tonight but don't know what to get.
I usually just drink Busch Light as I'm not a fan of heavy or dark beers. What would one suggest?
I usually just drink Busch Light as I'm not a fan of heavy or dark beers. What would one suggest?
Chris--after all of your guzzling, could you update us on your favorite pumpkin varieties? I kind of like Shock top
Shock top is drinkable but it's far from the best or something I would buy given other options. I would like an update also on the rankings.
I'm a Bud Light guy, I'd prefer better beers but those student loans don't pay themselves.
Had a Jack-O Shandy from Traveler last night. Really thought it was good. Probably more pumpkin flavor than any other I've tried and a nice hint of lemon in the background.
New Holland's Ichabod is selling pretty well. I don't know if that is in bottles in Iowa or not.
Just cracked one of these open tonight. I think this just took my top spot over Schlafly, it's amazing. Although, more expensive and harder to find.
Just tried Schlafly's because of this thread and I know what I'm drinking while I tailgate this weekend. Amazing and 8% alcohol.
I'd had my pumpkin beer tour, but I saw this and it looked like a good choice to throw in there, mainly because Rogue makes cool bottles. Rogue Pumpkin Patch Ale. Mild but a decent flavor. I'd say around ♦♦♦-♦♦♦½. Worth trying, but maybe not sure about the price.
Last edited:
