***2023-24 College Football Thread***

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,682
80,074
113
DSM
Perhaps this has already been discussed, but one of the reasons they said they dropped FSU was because of the QB injury. With that logic shouldn't they have been dropped 3 games ago after the QB got hurt? Shouldn't have been in the top 4 before this week anyway...if you use their logic.

The punishment should be losing games if the QB situation is such a big deal. That didn’t happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawaiiClone

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,392
55,305
113
If an OL gets injured and a team's running game takes a huge dip for a few games....what then?

The Michigan QB looked pretty pedestrian last night....they didn't drop any.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawaiiClone

Cy Guy69

Active Member
Nov 2, 2023
452
91
43
Late to the party but a couple thoughts

Leaving FSU out is the correct move in this season. But if the committee was going to do this, they should have dropped them before the championship game.

Thank god we didn’t get two SEC teams. I think this is the most intriguing playoff since the first couple.

Lastly, I hate the idea that Texas probably makes the championship game, but at least it counts as a big 12 one.
 

CycloneSpinning

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2022
1,055
1,354
113
44
The NCAA doesn’t run the CFP, but it does recognize the winner and declares who can claim the title of national champion. UCF went through this with the NCAA with their undefeated season.

And based on that precedent, if FSU finishes undefeated they should absolutely claim a national title and do the parade and rings. Just like UCF did.
I would say they have a strong case if they beat Georgia and Texas or Alabama otherwise win the “National Championship” game. Of course, if they lose to Georgia, the committee will be basically proven right.
 

Clonehomer

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
26,905
25,036
113
I would say they have a strong case if they beat Georgia and Texas or Alabama otherwise win the “National Championship” game. Of course, if they lose to Georgia, the committee will be basically proven right.

That’ll be the narrative. But we all have seen where these bowls are just as much about who wants it than the best team. I’d be surprised if FSU will be fielding anything close to the team they would have had in the playoffs. Guys are going to opt out or just not care that much.
 
  • Agree
  • Winner
Reactions: BigCyFan and Spam

Spam

Well-Known Member
May 21, 2008
7,996
2,666
113
That’ll be the narrative. But we all have seen where these bowls are just as much about who wants it than the best team. I’d be surprised if FSU will be fielding anything close to the team they would have had in the playoffs. Guys are going to opt out or just not care that much.

Exactly. The media might hype up their bowl as their chance to prove the committee wrong. But neither FSU nor Georgia are going to be giving the game their best shot.
 

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,923
66,403
113
LA LA Land
Whoever scheduled the series with Alabama for Texas very likely got them a playoff spot and booted fsu.

A time when scheduling a crazy hard game paid off huge.
 
  • Like
Reactions: exCYtable

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,923
66,403
113
LA LA Land
FSU scheduled 2 SECs and it didn’t help them.

Yeah it’s a lot of luck.

Going forward I think the best big 12 and ACC teams should try to play some series or neutral site against big 10/sec if they can. A loss won’t matter for the auto bid and a win could force the biased committee to give an at large spot.

Hopefully there are some perennial powers that emerge.
 

simply1

Rec Center HOF
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 10, 2009
45,921
34,664
113
Pdx
Yeah it’s a lot of luck.

Going forward I think the best big 12 and ACC teams should try to play some series or neutral site against big 10/sec if they can. A loss won’t matter for the auto bid and a win could force the biased committee to give an at large spot.

Hopefully there are some perennial powers that emerge.
B1g and sec don’t gain anything from that
 

jctisu

Well-Known Member
Jun 11, 2017
8,726
10,674
113
Bill Connelly wrote a great article about the takeaways from this weekend, but the main one and first section of the article talks about the Florida State snub and how wrong it actually was. It's behind the ESPN+ paywall, but if you have ESPN+ give it a read. He lays out actual data and metrics and examples all over the place as to why this decision was basically a bunch of *********.

 

Three4Cy

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2010
4,258
2,889
113
West Des Moines
I think this is the bigger issue. Yes, FSU got robbed this year. But it is the constant mental gymnastics the committee engages in every year that clearly comes from their preference and bias towards the Big 10 and SEC.

The “criteria” is either shifted or a new term is entered into the discussion. If FSU’s situation was instead OSU or Alabama there’s no questioning of their resume or season results due to the QB injury. The narrative would be “they earned a spot by winning all their games.”
You mean - FSU isn't the same team without their starting QB. It doesn't matter that the rest of the team stepped up when their top two QBs went down, and they still won out and won their conference championship game.

When the committee chair was asked about Michigan during the Harbaugh suspension, he said something to the effect of "the players stepped up and led them during his absence," and the committee took that into account.

Wait a minute - isn't that the same thing FSU did when their starting QB and second-string QB got hurt? The team stepped up and found ways to win games against two P5 teams by playing stellar defense.
 
Last edited:

stewart092284

Well-Known Member
Sep 22, 2021
2,452
2,300
113
40
Yeah it’s a lot of luck.

Going forward I think the best big 12 and ACC teams should try to play some series or neutral site against big 10/sec if they can. A loss won’t matter for the auto bid and a win could force the biased committee to give an at large spot.

Hopefully there are some perennial powers that emerge.
Heck no. I want Akron, Kent State and ULM every year. Games don't matter.

Get me 3-0 every off-season, then if I win 6-7 games in a P5 in league, I'm 9-3 and or 10-2 and have a really strong chance of getting in if even at 6-3 I'm in the conference title game. And worst case scenario I'm winning 9 games a year
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigCyFan

Kinch

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2021
5,794
5,889
113
Heck no. I want Akron, Kent State and ULM every year. Games don't matter.

Get me 3-0 every off-season, then if I win 6-7 games in a P5 in league, I'm 9-3 and or 10-2 and have a really strong chance of getting in if even at 6-3 I'm in the conference title game. And worst case scenario I'm winning 9 games a year
Or Join the big 10 west.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron