ISU vs. CU postgame thread

Wesley

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
70,923
546
113
Omaha
Maybe a question for discussion:

Which is less painful to watch if you treat them as your own?
Iowa offense?
ISU offense?
Wayne Clone defense?
ISU football offense?
 

CYKOFAN

Well-Known Member
Mar 27, 2006
4,947
120
63
Good post, Kingcy. We could have used a few more posts like this when Morgan and the players were getting raked for having a mediocre season.
 

ISUChippewa

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 10, 2006
7,272
7,646
113
Whats this great foundation that Greg got when he got here???? Ohhh your talking about Jiri and Rashon... WOW!!!! National championship calliber there. No offense to them, they are nice guys but not exactly Kansas calliber. The rest of the team left, because Wayne encouraged them too. Its been repeated, documented and well discussed on this board that Wayne wanted nothing more then TO BRING DOWN ISU BASKETBALL FOR FIRING HIM....


AAARRRRRGGGGHHHHHH!!!!!!! Why, oh why, do we have to put up with posts like this? It has been well-documented, actually, by Rahshon Clark's fiance, that Wayne did NOT tell his former players to leave is an attempt to get revenge on Iowa State.

This is one of the unfortunate side effects of the internet, I think. Some people think that having access to all sorts of information (or even just opinions or second-hand information) makes them a freakin' expert on everything, and I'm getting damn sick and tired of people demanding that others respect and beleive their own made up versions of what they consider as facts.

Sorry to go on a rant, but that comment there really p1ssed me off. Remember, everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but you are NOT entitled to your own version of the facts.
 

ISUChippewa

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 10, 2006
7,272
7,646
113
No one can blame McDermott for Morgan getting fired and everyone here wants us to be successful, but ultimately, Pollard may have set the program back many years for "fixing" something that wasnt really broken in the first place..

Great post! I like you already, even if you are brand new.

For me, it's "water over the bridge" in regards to Wayne being fired and McD being hired. It's done with, it's over, it's time to keep on moving forward.

With that being said though, I do sometimes think myself that Pollard may have pulled the trigger a little bit quickly. I do think that McD is a better "x's and o's" and bench coach than Morgan, but I don't know if Wayne should have been fired for having one bad season, as disappointing as it was.
 

cy1225

Member
Oct 6, 2007
245
8
18
No one can blame McDermott for Morgan getting fired and everyone here wants us to be successful, but ultimately, Pollard may have set the program back many years for "fixing" something that wasnt really broken in the first place..

Great post! I like you already, even if you are brand new.

For me, it's "water over the bridge" in regards to Wayne being fired and McD being hired. It's done with, it's over, it's time to keep on moving forward.

With that being said though, I do sometimes think myself that Pollard may have pulled the trigger a little bit quickly. I do think that McD is a better "x's and o's" and bench coach than Morgan, but I don't know if Wayne should have been fired for having one bad season, as disappointing as it was.

You said it all. Terrible decsion.
 

CYKOFAN

Well-Known Member
Mar 27, 2006
4,947
120
63
Good posts ISUChippewa- I too want to look forward to the future, but people continue to bring up Wayne and I guess when a coach gets fired, there will naturally be comparisons to the new coach. So far Wayne stacks up pretty good, and as far as Wayne trying to talk kids into transferring, the one on the board in the best position to know the truth of that is Cyfan13, and I believe her. Wayne has never indicated any hate for ISU, though some would in his position. At the 100 year reunion they ran a clip on the big screen with former coaches, including Wayne. He was completely complimentary to the ISU fans and University with not a hint of bitterness. He was pure class all the way.
 

cy1225

Member
Oct 6, 2007
245
8
18
Wayne wasn't fired because we weren't winning, it was because he wasn't JP's guy, and his teams weren't disciplined. He had the talent, but not the discipline.[/QUOTE

Seemed to have the discipline to take us to the Final 4 of the NIT and the second round of the NCAA Tournament. Not to mention beating Texas and KU on their home floor.
 

isucyfan

Speechless
Apr 21, 2006
21,371
5,642
113
52
Saint Paul, MN
You said it all. Terrible decsion.

Wayne wasn't fired because we weren't winning, it was because he wasn't JP's guy, and his teams weren't disciplined. He had the talent, but not the discipline.[/QUOTE

Seemed to have the discipline to take us to the Final 4 of the NIT and the second round of the NCAA Tournament. Not to mention beating Texas and KU on their home floor.

Seems like you're a WM guy...I don't think he was a great coach, but it certainly admirable what he did for us after the LE situation.

Question: What would you have done if you were the AD in that situation? How long would you have given him?
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
We agree...I think. I'm not giving coach a pass, he is building his body of work from Day 1. Our differences may lie in the fact that I think he will turn it around, you seem to not think so. I could be wrong on this, but then again so could you.:wink:

I don't know what will happen but the signs at this point are not that encouraging.
 

CycloneErik

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2008
108,178
53,434
113
Jamerica
rememberingdoria.wordpress.com
Whats this great foundation that Greg got when he got here???? Ohhh your talking about Jiri and Rashon... WOW!!!! National championship calliber there. No offense to them, they are nice guys but not exactly Kansas calliber. The rest of the team left, because Wayne encouraged them too. Its been repeated, documented and well discussed on this board that Wayne wanted nothing more then TO BRING DOWN ISU BASKETBALL FOR FIRING HIM....


AAARRRRRGGGGHHHHHH!!!!!!! Why, oh why, do we have to put up with posts like this? It has been well-documented, actually, by Rahshon Clark's fiance, that Wayne did NOT tell his former players to leave is an attempt to get revenge on Iowa State.

This is one of the unfortunate side effects of the internet, I think. Some people think that having access to all sorts of information (or even just opinions or second-hand information) makes them a freakin' expert on everything, and I'm getting damn sick and tired of people demanding that others respect and beleive their own made up versions of what they consider as facts.

Sorry to go on a rant, but that comment there really p1ssed me off. Remember, everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but you are NOT entitled to your own version of the facts.

I heard a rumor that every former coach we've had calls every player every year and tells them to leave, so that coach Mac never matches their records.

I can't remember where I heard this one. It might have been when I made it up. I'm not sure anymore.
 

gocubs2118

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2006
18,599
2,829
113
37
Illinois
I don't know what will happen but the signs at this point are not that encouraging.
No offense but how the hell can you say that now. I am waiting until year #4 to give my final judgement. McDermott has been working with a bare cupboard for the past two year due to transfers and bad luck. I want to wait until he gets his own players in here and they have a couple of years in his system.
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
cyclone#1, I believe you should just let it go, bud. You aren't convincing anyone that your opinion is the correct one. Anyone who is paying attention has already formed their opinion and you prattling on and on about how your opinion is getting misconstrued or overly-bashed or whatever is getting old quickly. Actually, combine the tone of your messages with the fact that your forum name implies that you are the best ISU fan really seems to rub the wrong way with several people on this board. I would suggest re-evaluating the tone of some of your messages and keep in mind to try and keep future messages as non-demeaning as possible in order for your message to be taken seriously so that you do not have to post 20-30 times just to say something.

On another note, you say you want "your team" (quoted: "my team") to be successful "...period." What exactly do you mean by this? Are you implying that you would trade a good image for winning basketball, recruit criminals, cheat in order to win? what is your definition of successful?

Actually, I do not consider it my "problem" that people do not seem to comprehend relatively simple comments when written on this forum. I am not asking that anyone agree with me but don't continually take my words out of context of mis-characterize what I say.

I am not implying that I want to "win at any cost" but you seem to be implying that most of the teams that are winning must be cheating or recruiting bad character guys or something shady. Why is it so many of my Cyclone brethren seem to be fine with our losing if we have a "clean program"? I guess I don't find winning and running a clean program to be mutually exclusive things.
 

mwitt

Well-Known Member
Mar 23, 2006
5,838
182
63
Let me preface this by saying that I think it is fair to be critical of Coach McDermott and be skeptical of whether or not his system is one that can lead to our long term success. To be honest, I am very annoyed that our offense does not result in us taking many high percentage shots, but I'm not yet convinced that it's not going to be better with time. It's hard to believe that it won't get better, actually. With that said...

It has been well documented on this board that year 2 in the McDermott era has been his worst at every stop, and I'm willing to bet that is without the extenuating circumstances that he has faced while at Iowa State in regards to player turnover.

If our criteria for a bright future is annual improvement, then people better stop saying Wayne got screwed because when was the last time our basketball team underachieved as much as his last one did?
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
The game was on ESPN classic yesterday, last time I checked that is a national network, unless they do have regional coverage. Newspapers are becoming a thing of the past, if you want info it is on the Internet. There are not very many Top 25 highlights in the DSM reg anymore. If you want to watch them play more buy College Game Plan.
What do you want me to do write McD and tell him how to make is team better?
The reason you get attacked so much is the way you go after McD the the program. We dont care that you rip him all the time but its the way you do it. You rip a program you hardly see play, you rip players you never have saw play. You rip a coach that you never listen to talk. You sit there are say what you think but when facts are put infront of you cannot take it.

Who cares where McD came from, every program cannot go hire a coach with BCS conference experence. Look at how many MVC coaches now coach in BCS conferences. When McD was at UNI he was taking a program that didnt have much good history to NCAA tournys at a time when the MVC was at a very high point.

Thanks for your explanation of various media sources to access Cyclone coverage. You have really enlightened me. On the second hand, why don't you get your Cyclone info from where you want and I'll do as I please.

I don't "rip" the coach, the players, or the program. But clearly you do care a great deal if anything you perceive as "negative" is uttered on this board...hence the beat down of the opposing voice to your thoughts. You and your friends are the ones that can't take "the facts"...not me. I have seen ISU play on TV several times this year. Frankly, I think many of you might be getting a "McCarneyesque" sales job from McDermott...I'm glad I don't "hear him talk" other than reading his quotes online...it gives me a much more unbiased basis of thought in my opinion.

What good are those NCAA Tournaments that McDermott took UNI to doing for ISU?
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
So lets see.... It took Orr 4 years to turn ISU around. Greg is still in year 2???? Lets compare in a couple more years. I'm sick of YOU comparing this over and over and over again. Hey you don't like Greg. WE GET IT!!! YOU ARE THE MOST NEGATIVE, ANNOYING PERSON I SEE ON THIS SITE.

Greg left North Dakota after 1 year. He left for a better job and an opportunity to coach the college he played at. LIKE YOU WOULDN'T DO THE SAME. I think everyone on this board would take an opportunity like that. You included.

So we are two coaches removed and 7 years from our Elite Eight experience. OMG.... WE SHOULD BE NATIONAL CONTENDERS EVERY YEAR NOW.... There are several teams that get to the Elite Eight and never get there for a longer period then us.

Whats this great foundation that Greg got when he got here???? Ohhh your talking about Jiri and Rashon... WOW!!!! National championship calliber there. No offense to them, they are nice guys but not exactly Kansas calliber. The rest of the team left, because Wayne encouraged them too. Its been repeated, documented and well discussed on this board that Wayne wanted nothing more then TO BRING DOWN ISU BASKETBALL FOR FIRING HIM....

pillbottle-chillpills.jpg


Take some of these and carefully unplug your computer. You write some of the most insane posts and I'm sure several people are now dumber for reading them.

Hey, I didn't bring up the comparison...coachdags did. Why don't you go back and read a little more closely.

When have I ever said I don't like Greg. I have just questioned whether we are making progress under his leadership. It has nothing to do with "liking" someone...Pollard liked McCarney but he showed him the door because the program was not progressing.

The bottom line is that, as I tried to point out, comparing what McDermott inherited and the job he has done early in his time at ISU to what Orr inherited and the job he did early is absolutely ridiculous. Orr inherited a much worse situation and did a much better job. Frankly, McDermott couldn't carry Johnny's clipboard in my opinion,
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
So lets see.... It took Orr 4 years to turn ISU around. Greg is still in year 2???? Lets compare in a couple more years. I'm sick of YOU comparing this over and over and over again. Hey you don't like Greg. WE GET IT!!! YOU ARE THE MOST NEGATIVE, ANNOYING PERSON I SEE ON THIS SITE.

Greg left North Dakota after 1 year. He left for a better job and an opportunity to coach the college he played at. LIKE YOU WOULDN'T DO THE SAME. I think everyone on this board would take an opportunity like that. You included.

So we are two coaches removed and 7 years from our Elite Eight experience. OMG.... WE SHOULD BE NATIONAL CONTENDERS EVERY YEAR NOW.... There are several teams that get to the Elite Eight and never get there for a longer period then us.

Whats this great foundation that Greg got when he got here???? Ohhh your talking about Jiri and Rashon... WOW!!!! National championship calliber there. No offense to them, they are nice guys but not exactly Kansas calliber. The rest of the team left, because Wayne encouraged them too. Its been repeated, documented and well discussed on this board that Wayne wanted nothing more then TO BRING DOWN ISU BASKETBALL FOR FIRING HIM....
pillbottle-chillpills.jpg


Take some of these and carefully unplug your computer. You write some of the most insane posts and I'm sure several people are now dumber for reading them.

Rahshon's fiance who posts on this board says this is flat out not true because she was involved with these discussions.