ISU vs. CU postgame thread

shildreth

Well-Known Member
Mar 28, 2006
1,164
26
48
Phoenix, AZ
We have a coach that has not finished Year 2 of his tenure and some people are ready to call him a failure. This is all after the following happened within a two year span:

1. Blalock and Stinson leave early for the NBA.
2. Taggart, Degand transfer. We return no guards for McDermott's first season.
3. McDermott gets a few months for his 1st recruiting class.
4. Our best player, Mike Taylor, gets booted from the team before Season two. Our starting point guard transfers. We return no guards for season two.
5. Our second best recruit gets hosed and forced to miss a year.

McDermott has yet to have the option of playing a guard with actual D1 experience. Do you think that is important at all?

Don't foget Carr, McIntosh, Dunson, Vette & Marsden....
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
X's and O's...let's try for example our gameplan against Augustin of Texas this year...our gameplan to beat Missouri's press which was causing to's at a rapid pace...our gameplan vs Kansas last year...the last minute and a half of the game at Missouri last year was some of the best in game coaching I've ever seen...just a few gameplans and a couple x's and o's that Greg has done...you just obviously can't come to grasp the fact the talent on a team, is the most important factor in success...a horrible coach will win more with a great team, than a great coach will win with a horrible team, but you clearly don't realize that...Offenses look a lot better when the shots drop, or when a team has a guy that can get to the rim and finish. But right now our best penetrator is Garrett (who is a year of weights away from finishing on a consistant basis), and our best shooter (Lucca) is in street clothes. Tougher to execute when you don't have the guys to do it, but evidently you just can't grasp that.

Thanks for trying to come up with some concrete examples for me:

Texas this year - I watched this game (I actually see quite a few UT games on TV). I'm not so certain that DJ's game (17pts, 1reb, 3asst, 1to, and 2stls) was impacted that dramatically by anything we were doing. He had a decent game and actually was in a little bit of a "slump" during that stretch. However, WE LOST THE GAME.

Missouri this year -I didn't see this game but at least we won the game by 5 at home...that is good. However, one thing I know, Anderson, who is a disciple of Nolan Richardson, loves to press and try to create easy baskets in transition and basically outscore the other team in a fast-paced game. This is much easier to do at home than on the road. If we can control the pace when we play them in Columbia I will be much more impressed. By the way...Mizzou is no "world beater" team...15-14 and in 10th place in the Big 12.

Kansas last year -I assume you are talking about the loss in OT at home. I did see that game on TV...but I just don't recall much of it...certainly nothing that made me think McDermott was a sterling X&O guy. The bottom line again is that WE LOST THE GAME.

I guess when I think of a good X&O coach I think of the following:

-A guy that can "out-coach" a team with superior talent and get a win that maybe he really shouldn't get.

-A guy that can develop a defensive scheme that will take the other team's best player out of the game and force someone else to beat you.

-A guy that has a team that can consistently score easy buckets from and inbounds situation under the offensive goal.

-A guy that has a team that can consistently score easy buckets when coming out of a timeout with the ball.

-A guy that has an offensive gameplan that yields easy buckets off the halfcourt set.

-A guy who can make in game adjustments to stop the flow of the other team. Self gave a great example of this against us last week...we came out hot in the second half and trimmed the lead to 6 (if I recall correctly) and he called timeout. A few minutes later we were down by 20+.

I clearly understand that talent is critically important...that's why I am a little concerned with recruits coming from small towns in Nebraska.
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
We have a coach that has not finished Year 2 of his tenure and some people are ready to call him a failure. This is all after the following happened within a two year span:

1. Blalock and Stinson leave early for the NBA.
2. Taggart, Degand transfer. We return no guards for McDermott's first season.
3. McDermott gets a few months for his 1st recruiting class.
4. Our best player, Mike Taylor, gets booted from the team before Season two. Our starting point guard transfers. We return no guards for season two.
5. Our second best recruit gets hosed and forced to miss a year.

McDermott has yet to have the option of playing a guard with actual D1 experience. Do you think that is important at all?

I wonder why in the world McDermott decided to take such a lousy job as the one at ISU? Did you ever think that he has some culpability in many of the points you list?
 

cyismydog

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
6,340
213
63
I wonder why in the world McDermott decided to take such a lousy job as the one at ISU? Did you ever think that he has some culpability in many of the points you list?
He took the one at ISU because it felt right. He could have had the Iowa job if he wanted it, and I'm sure other schools wanted him pretty badly.
 

kingcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 16, 2006
22,806
3,698
113
Menlo, Iowa
Guys let it die. You are never going to prove Cyclones#1 wrong. In his mind he is right and fighting the same points over and over doenst work. No matter what real facts you put out there he will find something to fight back with. Most of us think this program is headed in the right direction, those that dont think that way wont enjoy the ride to the top. Its sad to say we have fans that are this way but I guess we do. Like I said before being a fan is suppose to be fun, if you are not having fun with it why are you a fan? I think no matter who the coach we have to stand behind him and the team, more than ever as they go though rough times.
 

Aclone

Well-Known Member
Dec 14, 2007
26,966
23,601
113
Des Moines, Ia.
Just back to the "Post Game" thought, I wanted to say that it was nice to see Craig playing actively and with some confidence again. Hopefully this is the start of a run for him!
 

kg-cyclone

Well-Known Member
Oct 30, 2006
4,113
164
63
He took the one at ISU because it felt right. He could have had the Iowa job if he wanted it, and I'm sure other schools wanted him pretty badly.

When GM took the ISU job, he had two other offers and cancelled a few interviews...He wants to be here.
 

Clone_12

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 11, 2006
2,987
318
83
You watched the Texas game and you don't think we did a good job on Augustin??? Btw, that Missouri team was a COMPLETELY different team when we beat them, so thanks for posting their record now to prove your point, seeing as they lost their best player, among others...and they were ranked in the top 5 of the nation in creating to's...also if you've watched us more than a few games, you would know that we have scored plenty of easy buckets over the last couple years coming out of timeouts and on inbounds play...one more thing...clearly you do not realize that talent has a lot to do with winning or losing, or you wouldn't continually ridicule a guy for losing with this team against the likes of texas and kansas. And don't compare the 80's teams that beat Danny Manning to now, because the talent difference between the two in huge. A coach CAN do a good coaching job and have a good gameplan in a loss, and a coach CAN do a poor coaching job in a win. The majority of it has to do with what the kids on the court do. You are losing credibility (what little you have) with every post...especially the ones where you try to point out examples (things we have done, or ridiculous comparisons that don't make sense...loved your Wes Eikmeier to Patrick Beverly comparison btw, what a ridiculously random comparison between two completely different types of players).
Thanks for trying to come up with some concrete examples for me:

Texas this year - I watched this game (I actually see quite a few UT games on TV). I'm not so certain that DJ's game (17pts, 1reb, 3asst, 1to, and 2stls) was impacted that dramatically by anything we were doing. He had a decent game and actually was in a little bit of a "slump" during that stretch. However, WE LOST THE GAME.

Missouri this year -I didn't see this game but at least we won the game by 5 at home...that is good. However, one thing I know, Anderson, who is a disciple of Nolan Richardson, loves to press and try to create easy baskets in transition and basically outscore the other team in a fast-paced game. This is much easier to do at home than on the road. If we can control the pace when we play them in Columbia I will be much more impressed. By the way...Mizzou is no "world beater" team...15-14 and in 10th place in the Big 12.

Kansas last year -I assume you are talking about the loss in OT at home. I did see that game on TV...but I just don't recall much of it...certainly nothing that made me think McDermott was a sterling X&O guy. The bottom line again is that WE LOST THE GAME.

I guess when I think of a good X&O coach I think of the following:

-A guy that can "out-coach" a team with superior talent and get a win that maybe he really shouldn't get.

-A guy that can develop a defensive scheme that will take the other team's best player out of the game and force someone else to beat you.

-A guy that has a team that can consistently score easy buckets from and inbounds situation under the offensive goal.

-A guy that has a team that can consistently score easy buckets when coming out of a timeout with the ball.

-A guy that has an offensive gameplan that yields easy buckets off the halfcourt set.

-A guy who can make in game adjustments to stop the flow of the other team. Self gave a great example of this against us last week...we came out hot in the second half and trimmed the lead to 6 (if I recall correctly) and he called timeout. A few minutes later we were down by 20+.

I clearly understand that talent is critically important...that's why I am a little concerned with recruits coming from small towns in Nebraska.

 

cycloneworld

Facebook Knows All
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 20, 2006
30,190
22,541
113
Urbandale, IA
I wonder why in the world McDermott decided to take such a lousy job as the one at ISU? Did you ever think that he has some culpability in many of the points you list?

In case you didn't know, he is from the State of Iowa and likes it here.

He also had an offer from K-State and likely several others if he had waited.

Serious question: Who do you want to be coaching Iowa State right now?
 

mwitt

Well-Known Member
Mar 23, 2006
5,838
182
63
Missouri this year -I didn't see this game but at least we won the game by 5 at home...that is good. However, one thing I know, Anderson, who is a disciple of Nolan Richardson, loves to press and try to create easy baskets in transition and basically outscore the other team in a fast-paced game. This is much easier to do at home than on the road. If we can control the pace when we play them in Columbia I will be much more impressed. By the way...Mizzou is no "world beater" team...15-14 and in 10th place in the Big 12.

Are you aware of the problems Missouri has had this year? Suspensions, their best player being dismissed, etc. They were doing pretty well before that. And as far as their defense being much easier to implement when they're at home -- if you recall, they beat us by 22 (I believe) in Hilton last year. I'd say that's a pretty dramatic improvement.

cyclone#1 said:
Kansas last year -I assume you are talking about the loss in OT at home. I did see that game on TV...but I just don't recall much of it...certainly nothing that made me think McDermott was a sterling X&O guy. The bottom line again is that WE LOST THE GAME.

You were not impressed at all that we held a KU team to less than 70 points when they went to OT? With a team that was as poor as ours?

cyclone#1 said:
I guess when I think of a good X&O coach I think of the following:

-A guy that can "out-coach" a team with superior talent and get a win that maybe he really shouldn't get.

Purdue. At Missouri last year.

cyclone#1 said:
-A guy that can develop a defensive scheme that will take the other team's best player out of the game and force someone else to beat you.

Texas last year. We held Durant to his lowest point total to that point (it may have been his lowest all year, I don't remember) and DJ Augustin ended up beating us. This was also on the road.
 

DaddyMac

Well-Known Member
Oct 18, 2006
14,070
453
83
I clearly understand that talent is critically important...that's why I am a little concerned with recruits coming from small towns in Nebraska.

Why don't you get off the kid's back and let him prove if he's worthy or not.

For the life of me, I can't figure how someone from Louisiana can be so sure about a kid from Nebraska?

Did you want to axe Jared Homan as well - I mean he's from a small town in Iowa. Obviously he was destined to suck.
 

kingcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 16, 2006
22,806
3,698
113
Menlo, Iowa
InSerious question: Who do you want to be coaching Iowa State right now?

He wanted a coach with BCS conference experence. He has said Steve Lavin before, a guy like could have a coaching job if he wanted, but he must not since he is still with ESPN.
 

mwitt

Well-Known Member
Mar 23, 2006
5,838
182
63
He wanted a coach with BCS conference experence. He has said Steve Lavin before, a guy like could have a coaching job if he wanted, but he must not since he is still with ESPN.

Steve Lavin: The only person in the last half century who can have a losing record at UCLA.
 

isuno1fan

Well-Known Member
Mar 30, 2006
23,300
4,699
113
Clive, Iowa
I still think losing Floyd was the worst thing that has happened to this program.

We needed Tim to stick around and be the next Orr. His early exit to the Bulls initiated the downward spiral IMO (yes I know we had 2 of our best years after he left).
 

cyismydog

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
6,340
213
63
There's a reason Tim is never coaching teams for long, whether they're winning or not. (You can read whatever you want into this)
 

isuno1fan

Well-Known Member
Mar 30, 2006
23,300
4,699
113
Clive, Iowa
There's a reason Tim is never coaching teams for long, whether they're winning or not. (You can read whatever you want into this)

I know, I know...you believe his hands aren't totally clean. I don't think he bends the rules any worse than Bill Self and nothing ever seems to happen to him.
 

nickwc

Well-Known Member
Mar 27, 2007
1,586
41
48
Denver, CO
There's always the Hawks for "fans" like you.

I, for one, love any team that has Cyclones across their chest, and watch them no matter what.

Oh please don't give me this crap because i said Iowa State is terrible that i should be a hawk fan, I have been to every single home basketball game this year and will go to the last one against k-state, but that doesn't mean that we aren't terrible. Can you honestly say that you don't have a hard time watching this basketball team right now? because i sure can. We are not a good team right now, so therefore i have a hard time watching them. Hopefully they can turn it around sooner rather than later. Just because i get frustrated with how below average we are right now does not make me a "fan".
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron