Death to Cyclone Alley!

HiltonMagic

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
6,163
211
63
CA
Visit site
For the fee of the membership: you get better seats and the opportunity to represent the fanbase on national television.

Benefit CA "could" provide the AD: If the students would buy into the idea of Cyclone Alley, it would be an amazing sight for TV and recruits. I realize most don't like the t-shirt thing, but a full Cyclone Alley in matching shirts is one heck of a sight. It intimidates the opponent, shows support when recruits visit, and provides a distinctive appearance on television.

How the **** do red shirts intimidate anyone? :twitcy:
 

Clonefan32

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2008
23,552
26,003
113
Whenever they pan across Cyclone Alley I become embarrassed. Everyone in CA looks like they are about 15 years old, clapping as though Phil Mickleson just hit an iron to within a few feet of the cup. I counted 3 times I saw someone in CA yawn while a camera was on them on Friday.
 

IcSyU

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2007
28,307
6,981
113
For the fee of the membership: you get better seats and the opportunity to represent the fanbase on national television.

Benefit CA "could" provide the AD: If the students would buy into the idea of Cyclone Alley, it would be an amazing sight for TV and recruits. I realize most don't like the t-shirt thing, but a full Cyclone Alley in matching shirts is one heck of a sight. It intimidates the opponent, shows support when recruits visit, and provides a distinctive appearance on television.

You're kidding yourself if you think its intimidating. If 14,000 people are screaming their lungs out, it doesn't matter (within reason) what they're wearing. Recruits will be impressed.

Screw the specific shirts, just tell people to wear a red freaking shirt.
 

iowast8fan

Well-Known Member
Aug 3, 2006
2,243
127
63
Ankeny
I support the idea of Cyclone Alley. I'm disheartened by the student turnout. I'd completely support a non-CA student section if it meant a better turnout. Unfortunately, I don't believe CA is the problem here. CA may have contributed to the decline, but I believe the students just have a different attitude towards basketball than they used to. I hate it. The team will need a couple great years to rebuild the student fan base.

Winning big games will breed a new student fan. Eventually the current students will graduate and take their lame attitude with them, and the new breed of students can begin to build a new hilton magic. I've given up on our current batch of students.
 

Clonefan32

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2008
23,552
26,003
113
You interview to join. But their selection process sucks. I know at least 2 HUGE fans who everyone knows because of their game day attire who were turned away. That shouldn't happen. Absolutely no excuse for it. I have another friend who is a huge fan but didn't even care about Iowa State until he came to school here, yet he got on. Still puzzles me to this day.

And frankly, most of the people on CAC are good people, its the AA that's the issue. You know, the embarrassment that'll hit the field at Jack Trice about 5:45 Saturday night? There's the biggest issue.

Just out of curiosity, why would the AA have anything to do with CA? Not trying to disagree with you, just curious why an alumni association would regulate a student organization...
 

iahawkhunter

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2010
3,065
423
83
Huxley, IA
Just out of curiosity, why would the AA have anything to do with CA? Not trying to disagree with you, just curious why an alumni association would regulate a student organization...

The earlier you can sink the money-hook, the deeper you can plant it and the less likely they'll get away.
 

Clone5

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2008
3,738
398
83
Iowa
CA has problems but it really isn't as terrible as some of you are making it out to be. As some posters have pointed out the problem is winning. There aren't too many people on campus right now that are huge ISU basketball fans. This would obviously change if we have 2-3 years of consistent winning but until then we are still going to have problems with student, and general, attendance.
Is CA kind of lame? Yes, but fans aren't forced to follow the dumb cheers and stuff they come up with.
 

cyclonepower3

New Member
Dec 2, 2009
27
3
3
Ames
Since there are a couple of CA apologeticists in this thread, here's a question for you: what value-added product/service/experience does CA bring to a basketball game?

CA charges students a fee for their membership, so it is reasonable to expect students to realize some benefit for their fee that they would not have with a general student section (and I'd like to see an answer better than "they get to be a part of CA"). Along those lines, what benefit does CA provide to the AD and the general-public's gameday experience as compared to having a general student section?

I went on the roadtrip to Nebraska last year and thought it was a pretty awesome experience...the gamewatches aren't terrible and as for home games I think it looks sweet having everyone in the same shirt and if they have a good prop then it makes things better....as for the organized cheers, I overheard Royce White say "thats sweet I don't know if i could make it looking into that"....that actually changed my opinion of that from last year to this year
 

Clone5

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2008
3,738
398
83
Iowa
Whenever they pan across Cyclone Alley I become embarrassed. Everyone in CA looks like they are about 15 years old, clapping as though Phil Mickleson just hit an iron to within a few feet of the cup. I counted 3 times I saw someone in CA yawn while a camera was on them on Friday.
I'm sure nobody ever yawned back in the 90's! :jimlad:
Honestly though give the students a product they can really cheer about on the court and that will solve most, if not all, of the problems we are discussing here. That might not be right but its true of every fan base in the nation. Exciting, winning basketball= better fans.
I have a feeling next year will help that.
 

alarson

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 15, 2006
59,611
74,452
113
Ankeny
5.) Requiring students to wear the shirt kills attendance because it's harder to transfer the tickets.

For sure. Cant even give the tickets away. Something that is important when comparing regular seats and student seats. How many there were there in season ticket holders seats that were sold to them, often for cheap? I know there were some around us that this was the case for today, and i know of a group of tickets in the parquet from another donor that were sold to someone. If youre in CA? Youre stuck, those tickets have no value whatsoever without the tshirt.
 

IcSyU

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2007
28,307
6,981
113
Whenever they pan across Cyclone Alley I become embarrassed. Everyone in CA looks like they are about 15 years old, clapping as though Phil Mickleson just hit an iron to within a few feet of the cup. I counted 3 times I saw someone in CA yawn while a camera was on them on Friday.

Yes, because in 2002? when we played Eastern/Western Illinois and Binghamton in the Cyclone Challenge Hilton was ROCKING! Those games were pathetic and I remember them like yesterday. For some reason, people's memories fade as time goes on and they suddenly think that every single game, Hilton was rocking. Truth be told, that isn't anything close to true. I've been going to games since 1996, and I can't think of a single game where we've played a no-name school that it has been rocking in Hilton. Yes, every year we play Iowa, Drake, UNI, etc. there are people, and some non-conference showdowns (Virginia for example....Stinson-Blalock-Clark....prettttty!) have a great environment, but Savannah State, Western Illinois, Alabama State, Morningside (I think we damn near got beat?), Iona, etc. have NEVER had great environments.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bigcyfan82

alarson

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 15, 2006
59,611
74,452
113
Ankeny
Yes, because in 2002? when we played Eastern/Western Illinois and Binghamton in the Cyclone Challenge Hilton was ROCKING! Those games were pathetic and I remember them like yesterday. For some reason, people's memories fade as time goes on and they suddenly think that every single game, Hilton was rocking. Truth be told, that isn't anything close to true. I've been going to games since 1996, and I can't think of a single game where we've played a no-name school that it has been rocking in Hilton. Yes, every year we play Iowa, Drake, UNI, etc. there are people, and some non-conference showdowns (Virginia for example....Stinson-Blalock-Clark....prettttty!) have a great environment, but Savannah State, Western Illinois, Alabama State, Morningside (I think we damn near got beat?), Iona, etc. have NEVER had great environments.

This is true. I dont know if it was ever as empty as today, but these nonconference no-name teams are always empty. Perhaps people dont remember how bad they were because they skipped them too. :twitcy:
 

IcSyU

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2007
28,307
6,981
113
Just out of curiosity, why would the AA have anything to do with CA? Not trying to disagree with you, just curious why an alumni association would regulate a student organization...
I'm pretty sure the AA runs everything down to SAA, SALC, and CA. CA is not an athletics department entity like it probably should be.
For sure. Cant even give the tickets away. Something that is important when comparing regular seats and student seats. How many there were there in season ticket holders seats that were sold to them, often for cheap? I know there were some around us that this was the case for today, and i know of a group of tickets in the parquet from another donor that were sold to someone. If youre in CA? Youre stuck, those tickets have no value whatsoever without the tshirt.

You can still give them away, the person getting the tickets is just stuck in the upper level.
 

Tre4ISU

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 30, 2008
28,211
9,323
113
Estherville
Well, this is awkward. I agree with IcSyU. I don't think CA does much good, but I also don't think they do harm. Someone asked that since Fred doesn't have pull with current students (he doesn't, it is true) what would have pull. Winning. Winning would pull students. The difference between football and basketball fan attendance begins and ends with two things: The social aspect and it always being on Saturdays in generally nicer weather. I can name you 5 people off the top of my head who hold season football tickets but not basketball and I wouldn't say their amount of caring about the two is any different. It's pretty simple. When we start winning, people will stop caring about CA.
 

wxman1

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jul 2, 2008
19,961
16,349
113
Cedar Rapids
I agree Jeff Johnson is probably one of the biggest problems. As much fun as the Nebraska trip was last year I sat behind the CAC members and Jeff and his wife on the bus and let's just say Jeff has them eating out of his hand...
 

crash_zone

Well-Known Member
Apr 10, 2006
1,916
498
83
Sioux Falls, SD
Cyclone Alley does hurt attendance. My senior year, I wasn't going to pay for being in CA when I'd already boughten student tickets, and I didn't want to sit in the upper level when there were lots of empty seats down below in the student section.....so I just watched games on TV. CA just felt like a "class" system. No thanks.
 

greatshu

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2007
2,379
234
63
KS
It's a Sunday 1 p.m. tip against a bad opponent, did you expect a jam packed frenzied Hilton?

Hell yes. I went to every game regardless who we played when I was in school. I even went to the game by myself when we had TONS of snow outside because nobody else wanted to go with me.

God, I wish I lived in Ames, so I can go to all of the games.
 

greatshu

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2007
2,379
234
63
KS
Yes, because in 2002? when we played Eastern/Western Illinois and Binghamton in the Cyclone Challenge Hilton was ROCKING! Those games were pathetic and I remember them like yesterday. For some reason, people's memories fade as time goes on and they suddenly think that every single game, Hilton was rocking. Truth be told, that isn't anything close to true. I've been going to games since 1996, and I can't think of a single game where we've played a no-name school that it has been rocking in Hilton. Yes, every year we play Iowa, Drake, UNI, etc. there are people, and some non-conference showdowns (Virginia for example....Stinson-Blalock-Clark....prettttty!) have a great environment, but Savannah State, Western Illinois, Alabama State, Morningside (I think we damn near got beat?), Iona, etc. have NEVER had great environments.

Morningside game was awesome. I still remember that game....
God, that was like... 10 years ago.
 

Tornado man

Well-Known Member
Sep 16, 2007
11,913
-539
113
63
Ames, IA
Yes, every year we play Iowa, Drake, UNI, etc. there are people, and some non-conference showdowns (Virginia for example....Stinson-Blalock-Clark....prettttty!) have a great environment, but Savannah State, Western Illinois, Alabama State, Morningside (I think we damn near got beat?), Iona, etc. have NEVER had great environments.

That's why Wednesday's game against Drake will be very telling.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron