Hardest Colleges To Get Into for 2023

cyclone13

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2009
3,335
1,220
113
I'm wondering about HS performance's impact on college admission and financial aid ... (not just from Cyclone13 ... from anyone)

My son is an 8th grader, very intelligent. He has consistently taken math up 1 grade.

Because we value trying hard and habits of character, we have pushed him to take challenging classes (and he's in a private school that is rigorous).

My sister, who has kids that are older, would say that we're doing it all wrong. Her point is that you should take the fluffiest classes possible, get the highest GPA possible, because it's just "a game" for college admission and scholarships, and you need to look good on paper.

To a degree, she's right -- my son might end up with a 3.2 GPA while being challenged, whereas if he took easy classes at an easier school, he might be 3.9. (Even though he could likely run circles around the kids to took nothing but "fluffy" classes.)

Who's right?

(EDIT: he says he wants to go into Engineering or computer science, etc. If that matters. And I know lots of kids change their mind.)

Regular schools take GPAs only. Excellent schools look at rigors. Your B+ in AP or dual enrollment classes will look better han A in regular (non-honors or non AP).

Excellent/selective schools actually will do a deep analysis on the schools especially if they are reputable high schools. The colleges know what courses offered at HS and they could see whether the students coast at HS or challenge themselves.
 

FriendlySpartan

Well-Known Member
Jul 26, 2021
9,712
10,168
113
38
Regular schools take GPAs only. Excellent schools look at rigors. Your B+ in AP or dual enrollment classes will look better han A in regular (non-honors or non AP).

Excellent/selective schools actually will do a deep analysis on the schools especially if they are reputable high schools. The colleges know what courses offered at HS and they could see whether the students coast at HS or challenge themselves.
The quality of the high school is a major issue as well. You want to be on either end of the spectrum, a star at a great school or a star at an extremely poor school. Legit had a friend in HS that was told by Stanford that our HS simply didn’t rank high enough to be considered. She ended up at northwestern instead and really liked it but a lot of that stuff matters to the very elite schools.
 

Mr.G.Spot

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 22, 2020
5,781
147
113
60
I have known that Grinnell College is supposedly an elite college but I don't think I know a single person who has gone there. It is bonkers to me that they have a nearly 3 billion dollar endowment.
They bought Berkshire stock in the 70's. A lot of females from east coast use Grinnel as a safety School of they don't get into Smith or Wellesley, etc.
 

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,808
31,201
113
Behind you
I have known that Grinnell College is supposedly an elite college but I don't think I know a single person who has gone there. It is bonkers to me that they have a nearly 3 billion dollar endowment.
It still is a Cyclone State.

Grinnell pulls from everywhere, more students from Illinois than from Iowa. Lots from Cali. As with every other school in the country not named Harvard, Yale, Princeton, or MIT, Grinnell is a top choice for many and a safety school for many.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: SCNCY

khardbored

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2012
10,238
7,581
113
Middle of the Midwest
Regular schools take GPAs only. Excellent schools look at rigors. Your B+ in AP or dual enrollment classes will look better han A in regular (non-honors or non AP).

Excellent/selective schools actually will do a deep analysis on the schools especially if they are reputable high schools. The colleges know what courses offered at HS and they could see whether the students coast at HS or challenge themselves.

Would schools like ISU, Purdue (for Engineering, computer stuff, etc) and similar take into account rigor?

Or do they JUST look at GPA / standard testing for admission & scholarships?
 

cyclone13

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2009
3,335
1,220
113
The quality of the high school is a major issue as well. You want to be on either end of the spectrum, a star at a great school or a star at an extremely poor school. Legit had a friend in HS that was told by Stanford that our HS simply didn’t rank high enough to be considered. She ended up at northwestern instead and really liked it but a lot of that stuff matters to the very elite schools.
Would schools like ISU, Purdue (for Engineering, computer stuff, etc) and similar take into account rigor?

Or do they JUST look at GPA / standard testing for admission & scholarships?
ISU only look at GPA. I think ISU and Iowa just require students to meet the admission index and as long as they meet the requirement, they are good to go. I might be wrong though.

Purdue might be a little bit more difficult but their admission rate for engineering is 37%. Not horrible but not crazily selective either
 

FriendlySpartan

Well-Known Member
Jul 26, 2021
9,712
10,168
113
38
Would schools like ISU, Purdue (for Engineering, computer stuff, etc) and similar take into account rigor?

Or do they JUST look at GPA / standard testing for admission & scholarships?
Everyone else can speak to the ISU part but most schools like Purdue rerank things like GPA. Also some schools let you come in as a certain major, others you have to apply for a specific major, and for some high demand you have to apply for entry while already enrolled after your freshman/soph year.
 

carvers4math

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
21,353
17,736
113
AAU is based on grant money at the graduate level, ND does very little research, and has few masters programs. I doubt that AAU would even bother giving them a look. World class undergraduate school, with a top ranked Law and Med schools.
ND does not have a Med school. They do biomedical research and have a partnership with IU Med School in South Bend with various research areas including global health.

They have significant research in several areas and a nice nanofabrication facility.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Mr.G.Spot

SouthJerseyCy

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2008
1,885
2,045
113
56
The quality of the high school is a major issue as well. You want to be on either end of the spectrum, a star at a great school or a star at an extremely poor school. Legit had a friend in HS that was told by Stanford that our HS simply didn’t rank high enough to be considered. She ended up at northwestern instead and really liked it but a lot of that stuff matters to the very elite schools.
This is correct. And for the high end ones in this article, it's not only GPA, SAT, & honors curriculum, but also essays, volunteer work and frankly connections. Daughter was a 4.0 student taking all honors classes at a decent to good high school. Was either rejected or wait-listed by all the schools on this list that she applied. Still got into a 'good' school, but not on this tier. She's now top of her class in Med school, so their loss. :)
 

Kinch

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2021
5,786
5,886
113
They bought Berkshire stock in the 70's. A lot of females from east coast use Grinnel as a safety School of they don't get into Smith or Wellesley, etc.
It doesn't hurt to have the founder of Intel among your graduates.
 

SCNCY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 11, 2009
10,717
8,529
113
37
La Fox, IL
I knew that Grinnell was a good private school, I just never realized how selective it actually was based on what you all on here are saying.
 

stateofmind

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2007
6,635
4,174
113
Ankeny
Your sister is 100% wrong here. The schools weigh those harder classes differently. Once you submit your application the school (especially the elite ones) redo all that information. A kid that gets a 3.8 with all AP classes is going to get rated higher then a kid with a 4.0 with taking just basic or elective classes.

If you plan on going to grad school your undergrad doesn’t matter to the degree that it does if you plan on working right after undergrad. If they want to go to engineering go to the best engineering school possible. It pays off with connections and future relationships.
Yeah, the other advantage of the AP classes is that it counts toward college. My son started at ISU this year with 39 college credits. So he started 9 hours into his sophomore year. Saving me $25k give or take. ISU uses the RAI to admit, and he was admitted at the end of his junior year so it allowed him to apply for housing early and got his first choice, and some academic scholarship money. He was top 5% at Centennial and didn't study for ACT. He thought he could just retake whatever section he needed to raise it. He got a 25 or something and decided not to waste time or money retaking it as his RAI was around 280. My summary, quality of classes matter for a high school that uses the weighted GPA. If the high school doesn't she may be right.

Here is the RAI calculation:

RAI Formula​

ACT composite (or converted SAT) score x 3
+Cumulative GPA x 30
+Number of years of high school core courses x 5
RAI (Regent Admission Index)
Note: For purposes of calculating the RAI, SAT scores will be converted to ACT composite equivalents; high school GPA is expressed on a 4-point scale; and number of high school courses completed in the core subject areas is expressed in terms of years or fractions of years of study. *Grade-point average: Enter your high school grade-point average and scale. If your school provides more than one GPA (e.g. weighted GPA and non-weighted GPA), use the best GP

Applicants who achieve at least a 245 RAI score and who meet the minimum high school course requirements will automatically be offered admission. Applicants who achieve less than a 245 RAI score and who meet the minimum high school course requirements may also be offered admission, but their applications will be reviewed on an individual basis.
 

cyclone13

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2009
3,335
1,220
113
This is correct. And for the high end ones in this article, it's not only GPA, SAT, & honors curriculum, but also essays, volunteer work and frankly connections. Daughter was a 4.0 student taking all honors classes at a decent to good high school. Was either rejected or wait-listed by all the schools on this list that she applied. Still got into a 'good' school, but not on this tier. She's now top of her class in Med school, so their loss. :)

And this the one that I mentioned as "luck" factor - the essays are so subjective. There are no right or wrong.
Same with volunteer work: some were able to do "high profile" volunteering, some helped in the church's kitchen or Feed My starving Children and those can be judged differently.

Extracurricular activities can also be subjective. I was watching a video from one of the ACT/SAT Course prep that there are bias too. E.g for Asian students, doing Math Olympics, Science Olympics activities do not add more value in their applications because of the stereotyping that they are already good at those fields, but doing speech, debate, sports and student leadership would do. And vice versa to non-Asian students.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: khardbored

FriendlySpartan

Well-Known Member
Jul 26, 2021
9,712
10,168
113
38
This is correct. And for the high end ones in this article, it's not only GPA, SAT, & honors curriculum, but also essays, volunteer work and frankly connections. Daughter was a 4.0 student taking all honors classes at a decent to good high school. Was either rejected or wait-listed by all the schools on this list that she applied. Still got into a 'good' school, but not on this tier. She's now top of her class in Med school, so their loss. :)
Tell her to think long and hard about what speciality she wants to go in. Medicine is a mess right now.
 

jcyclonee

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
23,270
26,180
113
Minneapolis
This is correct. And for the high end ones in this article, it's not only GPA, SAT, & honors curriculum, but also essays, volunteer work and frankly connections. Daughter was a 4.0 student taking all honors classes at a decent to good high school. Was either rejected or wait-listed by all the schools on this list that she applied. Still got into a 'good' school, but not on this tier. She's now top of her class in Med school, so their loss. :)
I could've written almost the exact same paragraph. Except, my daughter is still pre-med but she's at the top of her class and has a terrific MCAT score.