UNI/ISU. I hate to say it, but.....(sky falling thread)

URBCLONE

Well-Known Member
Mar 26, 2006
1,244
75
48
56
Urbandale
Re: How many Big 12 caliber players on this team?

Yep. But as Brackins showed tonight, it won't be as consistent as what the team probably needs. Same with Garrett. I really like these 5 guys. The problems come when we dip into the bench. Maybe back to the good old TF days when we played 6 guys...and WON.

Right on Kramer. I was thinking of that myself. TF won 22 games in '96 with basically 6 guys. LE won 2 conference titles with at most a 7 man rotation. I think you can take a chance once in a while on 'diamonds in the rough', but fielding a large percentage of them is very problematic. I think we saw that in football under DM. I think they are several players on this team who simply do not have the talent to play at this level (Petersen, Haluska, Thompson, and Cory Johnson come to mind).
 

ISUKyro

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2006
12,727
2,345
113
Houston, TX
Re: Iowa State is NOT GOOD.

I always kind of laughed when you've said in the past that the board should be shut down for 24 hours after a loss. You're completely right.

That or we could leave the board open to view only. The mods could change the name of the team we played and we could just view the threads over and over :wideeyed:


***I'd better stop before they get more ideas*** :biglaugh:
 

everyyard

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2006
8,174
3,592
113
46
www.cyclonejerseys.com
Re: Iowa State is NOT GOOD.

Garrett is very, very athletic, and a very good ballhandler...he was Wisconsin's (much more talent than Iowa) runner up for Mr. Basketball. All he needs is to lift and grow into his body...he is also 6'4'' and has a very long wingspan. How in the world can you not see talent in this guy? (besides just not knowing much about basketball in general...granted you are the guy complaining that we had seven turnovers in a game)

We'll see. I am not the type to come back and say told you so but I am sure some one will point it out to me if he does find greatness. More power to him if he does.
 

jahfg

Well-Known Member
Apr 19, 2006
3,708
132
63
Ames
Re: Iowa State is NOT GOOD.

Garrett is very, very athletic, and a very good ballhandler...he was Wisconsin's (much more talent than Iowa) runner up for Mr. Basketball. All he needs is to lift and grow into his body...he is also 6'4'' and has a very long wingspan. How in the world can you not see talent in this guy?


Because he's not putting up a double double like everyyard expects out of freshman, obviously. For some reason, he thinks every freshman that comes in is going to be like that kid from Memphis.
 

everyyard

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2006
8,174
3,592
113
46
www.cyclonejerseys.com
Re: Iowa State is NOT GOOD.

That or we could leave the board open to view only. The mods could change the name of the team we played and we could just view the threads over and over :wideeyed:


***I'd better stop before they get more ideas*** :biglaugh:

or you could stop reading the threads you don't want to look at. too easy???
 

sodakjoe

Well-Known Member
Sep 15, 2006
2,799
119
63
Ames via Sioux Falls, SD
Re: Let's throw the team under the bus

And why there was not one postgame thread as usual, I'll never know...

I think that with the abundance of new memberships in the last few months, people may not know the "One postgame thread" rule. I know after many football games, the number of postgame threads was at about 5 or 6, which I suppose is tolerable, since at least they intend on discussing different topics. Maybe everyone just needs a reminder to keep these threads to a minimum. This is completely rediculous.
 

ArathornClone

Member
Oct 10, 2006
333
11
18
Re: "We were just plain outcoached."

Other than Brackins, I don't see the talent on this team. You can only coach so much. The talent level is not D-1 with what's onthe court IMO.

I agree with you in part that we don't have talented depth, but there is more D1 talent on this team than Brackins.

Rahshon Clark - talent - looks great this year 4 out of 5 games in double figures, plays great defense (4 blocks tonight)
Wes Johnson - THE most talented player on the team
DG - talent just really young and needs time
Brackins - offensively oozing with talent but streaky - needs time to develop consistent effort. Poor defense

Issues as I see it are
Wes is not 100% which is scary considering he put up 18 pts. tonight at less that full strength.
Brackins needs to be more consistent. But, his biggest issue is having consistent guard play to feed him the ball.
DG - young and inexperienced but really has a bright future

Moral of the story is we have youth, inexperience, and lack of talented depth in key spots, and Wes is injured. Give it time, this team will be playing much better by the time Big XII season rolls around
 

Wesley

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
70,923
546
113
Omaha
Re: Iowa State is NOT GOOD.

Please, Jiri, play like last year. Sean, you can score. Alex, you can block a shot. Just do it.

Lou Holtz
 

Prone2Clone

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2006
9,894
9,209
113
Re: How many Big 12 caliber players on this team?

Agree with all of the above. Too bad Garrett doesn't have more experience to handle the point guard spot now. Going to have to wait and also hope Buckley is a super stud, or this won't be the only long season we have to endure.
 

everyyard

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2006
8,174
3,592
113
46
www.cyclonejerseys.com
Re: How many Big 12 caliber players on this team?

I think you can take a chance once in a while on 'diamonds in the rough', but fielding a large percentage of them is very problematic. I think we saw that in football under DM. I think they are several players on this team who simply do not have the talent to play at this level (Petersen, Haluska, Thompson, and Cory Johnson come to mind).

Agree. You must say it better than I do...I get ripped for the same sentiment but possibly am more hostile in my tone.
 

IOWASTATE

Member
Oct 29, 2007
535
23
18
Ames
I think im gonna cheer for the cyclones cuz im a cyclone fan!!! If we win, awesome, if we lose, well, ill still come back next week and cheer for them again because im a CYCLONE FAN! I don't know why we get so caught up in "omg we dont have talent, or a good enough coach" You know something, I LIKE IOWA STATE! If anyone asks me ill tell them why yes I do like the cyclones and thats the short and long of it.

Yep that sounds about right
 

bmuff

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2006
1,583
48
48
Re: Iowa State is NOT GOOD.

I have faith in Coach Mac. I think he is a great coach, and I think he is recruiting pretty darn well.

Before the year began, even when Lucca was going to be in the mix, there were some, myself included, that realized ISU's inexperienced backcourt was going to cause some problems this year.

And in the games that they don't turn the ball over a lot, would they be able to make winning plays more often than not?

Because the guards, especially at point, that starts it all. And point guards take longer to develop than other players, IMO.

The amount of attrition and turnover this program has seen in McDermott's time on campus is unreal, perhaps unprecedented for major college teams that have not been on probation.

That is going to have an effect. And not much of that is due to anything GMac has done.

It's going to take time. This year is another rebuilding year. And without Lucca, that is certainly the case.

Years like this are not always easy to watch, but I think you have to be realistic about them and understand what they are. And wait for the Big 12 to play out, too.

Even then, the guard situation is a problem that will not be remedied this year, even if Lucca gets to come back for a part of the year. It's going to take more time.

This was a two to three year rebuild job, IMO, before we can begin to fairly evaluate Coach GMac.

That's just my take.

Jon, I'll agree with you to a point, but IMO GMac has NOT done that well in recruiting. Brackins and Garrett will be good, and Wesley is, but other than that, it's been a lot of whiffs. Look at next year...no Clark and Hubalik. Who is going to play the post with Brackins? Thompson? OUCH. Him, CJohnson and Vette all got schooled tonight vs UNIs undersized bigs. And the new signees Hamilton and Mann are completely underwhelming.

Then, right when guards Garrett and Buckley are starting to come around, ISU will lose WJ. GMac needs to recruit some difference makers and not just role players. He hasn't done that since Brackins.
 

SplitIdentity

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2007
11,475
3,054
113
Minnesota
Guys, the internet isn't for arguing....

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YRgNOyCnbqg"]YouTube - World of Warcraft - The Internet is for porn[/ame]
 

Clone_12

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 11, 2006
2,957
259
83
Keep in mind out of Petersen, Haluska, Thompson, and Cory Johnson...Petersen and Haluska came in as walk-ons and Cory Johnson was a Wayne Morgan recruit...everyyard-you are basically repeatedly ripping on Greg McDermott for one recruiting class (which has the potential to be the best in a LONG time)...and backing up your argument with nothing, except for the fact that these freshmen are not playing like upperclassmen.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron