Hardest Colleges To Get Into for 2023

ClonerJams

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 26, 2022
7,168
16,251
113
This is kind of why the AAU status on determining prestige is silly. Notre Dame is not an AAU school, yet they're on a list like this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyclone1209

carvers4math

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
21,353
17,736
113
I wouldnt have gotten into any of the schools.
You never know. There’s a lot that goes into it and factors that are not obvious. Notre Dame for example does take into account legacy of relatives who attended. Harvard got tougher when they got more applicants because of a very generous financial aid deal, making it harder to get into. At least when oldest was applying, Caltech did not consider race and gender or try to balance their student body based on demographics whereas MIT did. Maybe some school would have been intrigued by your answers to an application essay question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: khardbored

SEIOWA CLONE

Well-Known Member
Dec 19, 2018
6,793
6,989
113
63
This is kind of why the AAU status on determining prestige is silly. Notre Dame is not an AAU school, yet they're on a list like this.
AAU is based on grant money at the graduate level, ND does very little research, and has few masters programs. I doubt that AAU would even bother giving them a look. World class undergraduate school, with a top ranked Law and Med schools.
 

MuskieCy

Well-Known Member
Nov 4, 2006
3,635
5,879
113
Click bait.

Hardest diesel tech program to get in to is probably more important. The world does not need more art historians, Latin scholars or over-educated writers.

It needs more union laborers in all skilled trades, more money for front line health-care professionals and early age educators.
 

cyclone13

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2009
3,335
1,220
113
Having a child applying to colleges for next Fall, I see that the admission process to selective school is somewhat a lottery. I have heard the word “holistic” so many times in the last 15 months…..

First, you have to do the work: good GPA, test scores (although most schools make it optional, it never hurts to stand out), extracurricular, rigor of classes, etc. Now the essays are more important and this is when things get interesting as two people can have totally different opinions on your essays. This is the “lottery” factor.

You also have to compete against or sometimes benefit from citcumstances. Like my friend: her daughter goes to one of the colleges on the list because she is a good swimmer in HS - so she contacted the coach and she got a preference for admissions. I heard similar stories eg: the tuba player from the marching band graduates, and now if you play tuba, you might have a better chance for admission than someone with similar grades etc but doesn’t play tuba.

Public universities: it depends also on their funding: they might want to admit out of staters so they get more tuition. Some have different rules Like UNC (80% have to be in staters) Texas (75% have to be in staters and they have to admit the top 10% of each HS in Texas who apply IIRC).

Then you also have legacy admissions….
 

cyclone13

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2009
3,335
1,220
113
Click bait.

Hardest diesel tech program to get in to is probably more important. The world does not need more art historians, Latin scholars or over-educated writers.

It needs more union laborers in all skilled trades, more money for front line health-care professionals and early age educators.
It also needs good and kind people. Look at so many smart people but horrible human beings. I cringe whenever I see so and so graduated from top colleges and what they do is basically spreading hatred, laying off people while taking huge salaries for themselves, committing fraud etc.
 

NWICY

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2012
35,646
31,781
113
Having a child applying to colleges for next Fall, I see that the admission process to selective school is somewhat a lottery. I have heard the word “holistic” so many times in the last 15 months…..

First, you have to do the work: good GPA, test scores (although most schools make it optional, it never hurts to stand out), extracurricular, rigor of classes, etc. Now the essays are more important and this is when things get interesting as two people can have totally different opinions on your essays. This is the “lottery” factor.

You also have to compete against or sometimes benefit from citcumstances. Like my friend: her daughter goes to one of the colleges on the list because she is a good swimmer in HS - so she contacted the coach and she got a preference for admissions. I heard similar stories eg: the tuba player from the marching band graduates, and now if you play tuba, you might have a better chance for admission than someone with similar grades etc but doesn’t play tuba.

Public universities: it depends also on their funding: they might want to admit out of staters so they get more tuition. Some have different rules Like UNC (80% have to be in staters) Texas (75% have to be in staters and they have to admit the top 10% of each HS in Texas who apply IIRC).

Then you also have legacy admissions….

Make this simple and convince them to attend ISU. Unless they are super smart and can get into somewhere fancy like MIT, Stanford, Cornell and the like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wxman1

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,808
31,201
113
Behind you
Click bait.

Hardest diesel tech program to get in to is probably more important. The world does not need more art historians, Latin scholars or over-educated writers.

It needs more union laborers in all skilled trades, more money for front line health-care professionals and early age educators.
It still is a Cyclone State.

The long-time stigma on the trades, allied health, and other fields typically fed by community colleges and trade schools as being "inferior" to four-year liberal arts degrees is stupid and hopefully continues to be chipped away. There are good initiatives out there aimed at correcting this misperception. But that doesn't mean four-year degrees in the arts, writing, humanities, etc. aren't important, they bring a lot to the lives of a lot of people.
 

Trice

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2010
7,331
12,223
113
Media coverage surrounding higher ed is so weird. It's intensely focused on these relative handful of schools whose reputations are built on how hard it is to get in. Some higher ed professionals have taken to referring to them not as "highly selective" but the more derogatory "highly rejective." And for sure if you want to build a career in certain sectors of the economy - politics, parts of the federal government, tech, Wall Street - it helps to go there. But largely these places have turned themselves into playgrounds for rich kids and legacy admits.

Meanwhile, high-quality state schools and privates are educating scores more kids at a fraction of the cost*, and if you've got a decent high school resume you're almost sure to get in. No stressing about early decision or early admit, a lot less pressure, but less prestige. And yet the media is so obsessed with the rankings and elite schools that they pay no mind to where the vast majority of kids are actually going.

*not that college is "cheap" by any measure, even state schools have gone up dramatically. But it's still a pittance compared to an Ivy.
 

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,808
31,201
113
Behind you
Media coverage surrounding higher ed is so weird. It's intensely focused on these relative handful of schools whose reputations are built on how hard it is to get in. Some higher ed professionals have taken to referring to them not as "highly selective" but the more derogatory "highly rejective." And for sure if you want to build a career in certain sectors of the economy - politics, parts of the federal government, tech, Wall Street - it helps to go there. But largely these places have turned themselves into playgrounds for rich kids and legacy admits.

Meanwhile, high-quality state schools and privates are educating scores more kids at a fraction of the cost*, and if you've got a decent high school resume you're almost sure to get in. No stressing about early decision or early admit, a lot less pressure, but less prestige. And yet the media is so obsessed with the rankings and elite schools that they pay no mind to where the vast majority of kids are actually going.

*not that college is "cheap" by any measure, even state schools have gone up dramatically. But it's still a pittance compared to an Ivy.
It still is a Cyclone State.

I agree with your overall point but I wouldn't call it a fraction of the cost when one year at Wartburg comes in at nearly $58,000, Simpson at nearly $56,000, etc.
 

ClonerJams

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 26, 2022
7,168
16,251
113
It still is a Cyclone State.

I agree with your overall point but I wouldn't call it a fraction of the cost when one year at Wartburg comes in at nearly $58,000, Simpson at nearly $56,000, etc.
Wartburg and Simpson cost that much? That's insane.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Neptune78